This talk presents a comprehensive philosophy for designing large, dependable, and long-lasting software projects, using a video editor, a national healthcare system, and a jet fighter as illustrative examples. The central argument is that complex systems can be managed and scaled effectively by breaking them down into small, independent modules, each simple enough to be built and maintained by a single person.
The Black Box Module Philosophy
The core strategy is to modularize any large project into self-contained “black boxes.” Each module communicates with the rest of the system exclusively through a stable, well-defined API. This approach isolates developers, simplifies maintenance, and allows the internal implementation of any module to be completely rewritten without impacting other parts of the system, provided the API remains consistent. This modularity is key to achieving team scalability and consistent development velocity.
Identifying Primitives and Designing APIs for the Future
A crucial first step in designing a system is to identify its fundamental data “primitive.” For a video editor, the primitive is a “clip” on a timeline; for a healthcare system, it’s a “healthcare event”; for a jet fighter, it’s the “state of the world.” The entire application architecture is then built around creating, manipulating, and storing these primitives. When designing the APIs for these modules, it’s vital to think ahead. An API should be designed to support future requirements from day one, even if the initial implementation is simple. For example, a text-rendering function should accept parameters for different fonts and sizes, even if the first version only supports a single bitmap font. This prevents breaking changes down the line.
A Layered, Plugin-Driven Architecture
The speaker advocates for building applications in distinct layers, starting with reusable, generic components:
- Platform Layer: An abstraction layer that isolates the application from the underlying operating system (for windowing, input, etc.).
- Helper Libraries: Reusable modules for common tasks like drawing, text rendering, and networking.
- Application Core: A central black box that manages the system’s core data (the primitives) and enforces business rules and guarantees.
- Plugins: Most application-specific functionality (like video codecs, UI panels, or weapon systems) should be implemented as plugins. The core defines an API, and plugins register their capabilities, keeping the core lean and highly extensible.
Key Conclusion: Software Design is Format Design
The talk concludes that all software design is fundamentally format design. APIs, network protocols, and file structures are all formats that define how components interact. A successful system is built on simple, powerful, and easily implementable formats. By focusing on creating clean interfaces and hiding implementation details, you gain the freedom to evolve and improve the system over decades without being locked into initial technology choices.
Mentoring question
Consider a complex system you’ve worked on. What was its core ‘primitive’ or fundamental data entity? How could breaking it down into smaller, independent ‘black box’ modules with stable APIs have improved its long-term design and maintainability?
Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=sSpULGNHyoI&si=rkqFGnCIkJ-uf4UC
Leave a Reply