A recent longitudinal study published in JAMA Network Open investigated whether smartphone ownership among 12-year-olds correlates with the onset of eating disorder symptoms by age 14. Using data from nearly 9,000 participants in the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study, researchers evaluated whether early personal device ownership impacts how adolescents perceive their bodies and approach eating.
Key Findings and Numbers
The study evaluated four primary symptom areas: binge eating, unhealthy compensatory behaviors to prevent weight gain, fear of gaining weight, and linking self-worth to body weight. Researchers discovered that adolescents who owned a smartphone at age 12 had a 49% higher relative risk of reporting at least one eating disorder symptom at age 14, even after controlling for demographic factors, puberty, parental monitoring, and prior symptoms. In absolute terms, approximately 24% of smartphone owners reported at least one symptom by age 14, compared to 15.5% of non-owners.
Broken down by specific symptoms, early phone owners exhibited:
- A 67% higher relative risk of reporting binge eating behaviors.
- A 50% higher relative risk of improper compensatory behaviors.
- An approximate doubling of risk for basing self-worth on body weight.
- No statistically significant increase regarding the fear of weight gain (relative risk of 1.02).
Study Limitations: Correlation vs. Causation
While the study follows a temporal sequence over two years, it is observational rather than experimental. Consequently, it cannot prove that smartphones directly cause eating disorders. Key nuances include:
- Ownership vs. Behavior: The survey merely asked whether a child owned a phone, not how many hours they spent on it, which platforms they used, or what specific content they consumed.
- Symptoms vs. Clinical Diagnosis: Reporting a symptom on a survey does not equate to a formal diagnosis of conditions like anorexia or bulimia, nor does it capture the severity of the behavior.
- No Clear Age Threshold: The findings compare outcomes based on ownership at age 12 but do not determine a definitive “safe” age for a child to receive a device.
Actionable Takeaways for Parents
The study suggests that conversations around smartphones should extend beyond practical logistics and screen time to address content, emotional well-being, and body image. Recommended strategies derived from pediatric guidance include:
- Gradual Access: Introducing device capabilities incrementally rather than granting unrestricted internet and social media access immediately.
- Family Media Plans: Collaboratively establishing clear rules, including device-free times and keeping phones out of bedrooms before sleep.
- Professional Support: Seeking medical guidance if a child demonstrates severe food restriction, preoccupation with weight, or loss of control around food, regardless of their current weight or gender.
Mentoring question
How can parents and mentors transition from simply monitoring screen time to actively supporting a young person’s emotional resilience against toxic body standards online?
Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=60O7gjrGETE&is=pMmQKjGgYz83EICX