This article discusses Mechanize, a new startup founded by Tamay Besiroglu (co-founder of the think-tank Epoch), which launched with the ambitious goal of achieving “full automation of all work” and subsequently, the entire economy, using Artificial Intelligence.
Central Theme: The core idea is that AI agents, trained in sophisticated “simulated workplaces” mimicking real office tasks (complex computer use, long-term projects, coordination, shifting priorities), can eventually take over the full spectrum of human jobs. Mechanize aims to provide the infrastructure—datasets, benchmarks, virtual task environments—for developing these agents, positioning itself similarly to how AWS provides cloud infrastructure, targeting a market potentially worth $60 trillion globally.
Key Points & Arguments:
- Founder & Backing: Besiroglu, an economist focused on AI’s economic impact, has secured backing from prominent tech figures like Nat Friedman (ex-GitHub), Patrick Collison (Stripe), and Jeff Dean (Google AI), lending credibility to the venture.
- Optimistic Vision vs. Criticism: Besiroglu anticipates an explosion in productivity where AI assistance makes goods cheaper, maintaining prosperity through dividends or fiscal transfers even if wages fall. Critics, however, warn of mass unemployment and severe inequality without robust redistribution mechanisms, deeming the optimistic view unrealistic without policy changes.
- Technical Challenges: Current AI models struggle with reliability, long-term memory, adaptation, and error accumulation in tasks lasting weeks, posing a significant hurdle to Mechanize’s vision.
- Market & Standardization: Mechanize enters a competitive field (Microsoft, OpenAI, etc.) but hopes to become the foundational training ground. While standardization could streamline AI deployment, it also risks oversimplification or creating systemic vulnerabilities.
- Controversy: Besiroglu’s move from the supposedly impartial Epoch think-tank to a commercial venture using similar metrics has raised conflict-of-interest concerns.
Conclusions & Takeaways:
The article concludes that while the idea isn’t entirely absurd given AI advancements, full automation faces immense technical, economic, and socio-political obstacles. The most likely outcome is not a sudden revolution but decades of gradual automation waves, potentially causing social crises if policy and regulation don’t keep pace. Mechanize’s lasting contribution may be in standardizing AI agent training and measurement rather than immediate, widespread job replacement. Ultimately, technology alone cannot resolve the profound ethical and political questions raised by mass automation.
Source: Jego firma chce zautomatyzować całą gospodarkę. Mamy żyć w dobrobycie i oddać pracę AI
Leave a Reply