Core Question
This video embarks on an experimental journey to determine if a cheap, tough $1 eye of round steak can be elevated through various culinary techniques to match the texture and flavor of a premium $100 Wagyu steak.
Key Findings & Experiments
The process was broken down into two main challenges: improving tenderness and enhancing flavor.
Phase 1: Improving Tenderness
A wide array of methods were tested to break down the tough muscle fibers of the cheap steak.
- Fruit Enzymes: Fruits like pineapple, papaya, and kiwi were used as marinades. Asian pear proved to be the most effective, significantly tenderizing the meat without imparting an unwanted fruity flavor, explaining its common use in Korean BBQ.
- Chemical & Other Tenderizers: The experiment included lemon juice, buttermilk, baking soda, and even pickle juice. The decisive winner was a commercial powdered meat tenderizer, which was highly effective and also acted as a dry brine, enhancing saltiness without altering the steak’s core flavor.
- Mechanical Methods: While tools like a blade tenderizer and even running the steak over with a car were surprisingly effective, they tended to break down the steak’s structure, giving it a “hamburgery” texture.
Phase 2: Enhancing Flavor
To compensate for the lean cut’s lack of flavor, several techniques were tested.
- Fat & Butter: The most successful methods involved adding fat. Injecting the steak with rendered Wagyu tallow added immense juiciness and flavor. Additionally, butter-basting during the cook and resting the steak on herbed compound butter were game-changers.
- Umami Boosters: A combination of a simple dry brine, a sprinkle of MSG, and infusing the meat with cold smoke were all found to add significant savory depth and complexity.
Conclusion: The “Franken-Steak” vs. The Real Deal
The host created a final “Franken-Steak” by applying all the winning techniques: dry brine, powdered tenderizer, MSG, cold smoke, Wagyu fat injection, butter-basting, and compound butter. The result was a phenomenal success—the upgraded $1 steak was described as incredibly tender and flavorful, worthy of a $50 price tag in a restaurant.
However, in a direct taste-test against the genuine $100 Australian Wagyu, the premium steak was still undeniably superior in its natural richness and texture. The ultimate takeaway is that while you can use culinary science to dramatically elevate a cheap cut of meat, you cannot perfectly replicate the inherent quality of a world-class ingredient.
Mentoring Question
The video shows that many complex techniques still couldn’t perfectly replicate a naturally high-quality ingredient. When cooking for yourself or others, how do you decide when it’s worth putting in significant effort to improve a basic ingredient versus simply investing in a higher-quality one from the start?
Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=OMWrbaOxj3k&si=dC7r82AQKDeb0J54
Leave a Reply